Trips Places Foods Stories Newsletters

Take your next trip with Atlas Obscura!

Our small-group adventures are inspired by our Atlas of the world's most fascinating places, the stories behind them, and the people who bring them to life.

Visit Adventures
Trips Highlight
Macchu Picchu
Peru • 10 days, 9 nights
Peru: Machu Picchu & the Last Incan Bridges
from
Central Asia yurt night stars
Uzbekistan • 15 days, 14 nights
Central Asia Road Trip: Backroads & Bazaars
from
View all trips
Top Destinations
Latest Places
Most Popular Places Random Place Lists Itineraries
Add a Place
Download the App
Top Destinations
View All Destinations »

Countries

  • Australia
  • Canada
  • China
  • France
  • Germany
  • India
  • Italy
  • Japan

Cities

  • Amsterdam
  • Barcelona
  • Beijing
  • Berlin
  • Boston
  • Budapest
  • Chicago
  • London
  • Los Angeles
  • Mexico City
  • Montreal
  • Moscow
  • New Orleans
  • New York City
  • Paris
  • Philadelphia
  • Rome
  • San Francisco
  • Seattle
  • Stockholm
  • Tokyo
  • Toronto
  • Vienna
  • Washington, D.C.
Latest Places
View All Places »
Saquon Barkley Plaque
Kirkkasik Bedesten inside
Kirkkasik Bedesten
Someshwar Temple
Someshwar Temple
Grilled cheese and tomato soup are soulmates.
The Palisades Restaurant
Latest Places to Eat & Drink
View All Places to Eat »
The local catch is delicious fried as well.
Terry's of Charlevoix
Carlson’s Fishery is a Great Lakes institution.
Carlson’s Fishery
The Cathedral Café maintains the building’s original church exterior.
Cathedral Café
Exterior of the historic Dyffryn Arms pub.
Dyffryn Arms
Most of what’s on the menu here comes from Michigan.
The Glenwood
Recent Stories
All Stories Video Podcast
Most Recent Stories
View All Stories »
Siegfried Tieber specializes in sleight-of-hand magic using small objects, as well as mentalism, which gives the illusion of reading minds.
Does a Magician Really Never Reveal Their Tricks? AO Wants to Know.
12 days ago
Decoy’s wines reflect the terroir of California.
How a Wooden Duck Migrated From the California Wetlands to a Wine Label
14 days ago
There’s more to the French capital than the Eiffel Tower.
Dear Atlas: What Are Some Non-Touristy Things to Do in Paris?
18 days ago
The plants around Liz Dauncey in this photo are not poisonous, but many common garden and houseplants are.
Are Some of Your Favorite Houseplants Poisonous? AO Wants to Know.
25 days ago

No search results found for
“”

Make sure words are spelled correctly.

Try searching for a travel destination.

Places near me Random place

Popular Destinations

  • Paris
  • London
  • New York
  • Berlin
  • Rome
  • Los Angeles
Trips Places Foods Stories Newsletters
Sign In Join
Places near me Random place
All the United States New York State New York City East Hampton Gardiners Island

Gardiners Island

This private island is still in the family after a 400-year history including a witch hunt and a pirate.

East Hampton, New York

Added By
David Minkin
Email
Been Here
Want to go
Added to list
An aerial view of Gardiner’s Island   W. Marsh via Wikimedia
An aerial view of Gardiner’s Island   W. Marsh via Wikimedia
The island in winter   Doc Searls via Flickr
A famed windmill sits on the shore   Library of Congress via Wikimedia
Been Here
Want to go
Added to list

About

In 1639, this island in what is now New York State was settled by a man named Lion Gardiner. The island was made a proprietary colony, granted via a royal decree by Charles I that gave Gardiner “the right to possess the land forever.”

As far as forever goes, that remains to be seen. But the descendants of Lion Gardiner still hold the 3,300-acre island, making Gardiners Island the oldest estate in the United States and the only royal grant from the English Crown still intact in the country.

Over the last 400 years, the island has been embroiled in a series of contemporary flashpoints. In 1657, Gardiner’s first daughter Elizabeth would initiate the first witch hunt in an American colony when, at 15, her accusations of witchcraft led to the arrest and persecution of a farmhand's wife. In 1699, pirate Captain Kidd buried $30,000 worth of treasure—in rubies, diamonds, and bars of silver—on the island. He was kind enough to ask permission to do so, but also threatened to murder the family if the treasure wasn’t still there when he returned. Mrs. Gardiner, the island's proprietor at the time, was later ordered to deliver the booty to the court in Boston where Kidd sat trial. It was pretty compelling evidence for piracy—Kidd was executed.

In more recent years, the island has primarily made headlines for its strict no-trespassing policy and a contentious legal battle between two possible heirs. As of now, the island is unilaterally owned by Gardiner-descendant Alexandra Creel Goelet, who intends, predictably, to keep it in the family.

Related Tags

Islands Pirates Witches Estates

Community Contributors

Added By

The Minx

Edited By

PrestonW, hana

  • PrestonW
  • hana

Published

January 28, 2016

Edit this listing

Make an Edit
Add Photos
Sources
  • http://www.eastlongisland.com/islands/gardiners_island/gardiners_island_history.html
  • http://www.nytimes.com/1998/05/17/nyregion/closely-guarded-secrets-some-islands-you-can-t-get-to-visit.html?pagewanted=all
  • http://visit.easthamptonstar.com/Archive/1/Gardiners-Island-Again-Hands-One-Owner-Robert-Gardiners-death-leaves-niece-control
  • http://www.hamptons.com/Lifestyle/East-End-Heirlooms/13174/Gardiners-Island-A-Nearly-400-Year-Family.html#.VqjrYlMrJmA
Gardiners Island
Gardiner's Island
East Hampton, New York, 11937
United States
41.096667, -72.104167
Get Directions

Nearby Places

Green River Cemetery

East Hampton, New York

miles away

Plum Island Animal Disease Center

Orient, New York

miles away

Bear Rock Studio

Orient, New York

miles away

Explore the Destination Guide

Photo of East Hampton

East Hampton

New York

Places 3

Nearby Places

Green River Cemetery

East Hampton, New York

miles away

Plum Island Animal Disease Center

Orient, New York

miles away

Bear Rock Studio

Orient, New York

miles away

Explore the Destination Guide

Photo of East Hampton

East Hampton

New York

Places 3

Related Places

  • Coral Cut looking west

    Palm Beach, Florida

    Coral Cut

    This spooky road cut through a mound of ancient coral might be haunted by a witch.

  • The easternmost point in Denmark

    Gudhjem, Denmark

    Christiansø

    This remote island, home to the easternmost point in Denmark, once hosted pirates and a military fortress.

  • Parkersburg, West Virginia

    Blennerhassett Island

    Visit a replica of the estate where Aaron Burr allegedly plotted a treasonous scheme against the United States.

  • Strofades monastery.

    Moni Strofadon, Greece

    Strofades Monastery

    A lonely medieval monastery on an uninhabited island.

  • The footbridge to the island.

    Washington, D.C.

    Theodore Roosevelt Island

    The national park was once a plantation estate.

  • Ruins on Boa Vista

    Boa Vista, Cape Verde

    Curral Velho

    Once a bustling fishing village and trading post, today these Cape Verde ruins provide a home only for seabirds and turtles.

  • Nix’s Mate

    Winthrop, Massachusetts

    Nix's Mate

    A daybeacon pyramid is about all that's left of this island that is said to have sunk due to a pirate's curse.

  • Charles Island

    Milford, Connecticut

    Charles Island

    This "thrice-cursed" island is allegedly home to Captain Kidd's lost treasure.

Aerial image of Vietnam, displaying the picturesque rice terraces, characterized by their layered, verdant fields.
Atlas Obscura Membership

Become an Atlas Obscura Member


Join our community of curious explorers.

Become a Member

Get Our Email Newsletter

Follow Us

Facebook YouTube TikTok Instagram Pinterest RSS Feed

Get the app

Download the App
Download on the Apple App Store Get it on Google Play
  • All Places
  • Latest Places
  • Most Popular
  • Places to Eat
  • Random
  • Nearby
  • Add a Place
  • Stories
  • Food & Drink
  • Itineraries
  • Lists
  • Video
  • Podcast
  • Newsletters
  • All Trips
  • Family Trip
  • Food & Drink
  • History & Culture
  • Wildlife & Nature
  • FAQ
  • Membership
  • Feedback & Ideas
  • Community Guidelines
  • Product Blog
  • Unique Gifts
  • Work With Us
  • About
  • FAQ
  • Advertise With Us
  • Advertising Guidelines
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms of Use
Atlas Obscura

© 2025 Atlas Obscura. All Rights Reserved.